| I find myself questioning the appointment of Ruth Kelly to the posts of Minister for Women and Equality and Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government as potentially foolhardy, and so it seems does eveyone else including the more right wing media... Can a person of faith be the Minister for Equality - unequivocally yes is the answer in my opinion, as long as they work for the benefit of all the communities they are meant to support, but sadly it would seem that either by design or coincidence Ruth hasn't been available in her long career as an MP to support our community - infact she has only managed it once in 8 yrs and that was only a minor vote. Ruth also has made it clear that she is a member of Opus Dei ( a catholic religious order), whom according to their faith have a duty to extend the “holiness” of their beliefs into their everyday work life. Opus Dei regards practising homosexuals as sinners. Ruths voting record Nov 2004 Civil Partnership Bill 2 Absent Oct 2004 Civil Partnership Bill 1 Absent Mar 2003 Section 2a Repeal (Section 28 for Scotland) Absent Nov 2002 Adoption Rights for LGB 2 Absent May 2002 Adoption Rights 1 Voted Against LGB Equality and Against Party Policy Oct 2001 Civil Registrations Bill - Absent Jul 2000 Homophobic Bullying - Voted for LGBT protection mar 1999 Equalising the Age of Consent to 16 Absent Jun 1998 Reducing Age of consent to 18 for LGB - Absent (ref: www.publicwhip.org.uk/mp.php?mpid=1433&dmp=826) So there seems to me three explanations as to why this could be: 1. Ruth was absent for legitimate reasons for 8 out of the 9 important debates in the last 8 years on LGBT equality, which for me raises questions as to her priorities and whether she cares about the equality agenda for the LGBT community or, 2. Ruth has specifically absenteed herself because she doesnt want her true beliefs on LGBT rights to be expressed. or, 3. Some other reason that escapes me. I think we need to find out from Ruth exactly where she stands on LGB and T equality as In February 2004 she missed a vote to give transsexual people the rights of their new gender. let us not forget its a crucial time with several equality reviews currently going on within government and for which she is responsible for delivering on - she is our (very shared) voice and we need to make sure that she is treating our community equally and fairly. Over the last 36hrs the media has been trying to find out what she has been up to and here are her responses: Ruth Kelly, speaking to Nicky Campbell on Radio Five Live Nicky Campbell: As minister for Women and Equality with your deeply held religious beliefs and membership to the Opus Dei group of Catholics... do you think homosexuality is a sin? Ruth Kelly: I'm sort of getting used to these questions... about what it's like to be a Catholic in the middle of government. NC: I'm not asking about that... RK: That's exactly what you are asking, is it possible to be a practising Catholic and hold a portfolio in government? The answer is yes. Why? Because I'm collectively responsible for cabinet decisions and I firmly believe in equality... NC: Do you think homosexuality is a sin? RK: I don't think it's right for politicians to start making moral judgements about people ... What I think the question is, is what are my political views? Those are the ones that I'm accountable for to the public. As a politician I think everybody should be free from discrimination. Speaking to Kay Burley on Lunchtime Live on Sky News Kay Burley: What are your views on homosexuality? RK: As Equality minister I'm delighted to be taking on this brief. I was the minister who set up the equality review... KB: OK. What are your views on homosexuality? RK: Well, as I say I don't think people with different sexual orientations ought to be discriminated against in society and as a politician I will make it my responsibility and duty to ensure I have a society which is tolerant, which is fair... KB: In May 2002 I believe that you voted against same sex couples being able to adopt. Is that right? RK: Look, people have private views which they express in the House of Commons on votes of conscience in the usual way as members of Parliament. As a member of the Government, I have collective cabinet responsibility... KB: No, no no... you are the Equality minister. It's not collective responsibility. It's up to you to make sure everyone is treated equally... RK: And I will do that. What are NUS doing? A: Well I am writing to Ms Kelly to find out exactly where she stands on LGBT equality and how she intends to vote and steers the current Equality Agenda. We will also work with other key sector partners to monitor the situation and take further action if necessary. So what can I do? A:Well you can ask her exactly where she stands, if you are contacting make sure you are polite and courteous - otherwise your correspondence will be ignored: Write to her at the Houses of Parliment Telephone: 020 7219 3000 (parliament switchboard) eMail by visiting this link: www.locata.co.uk/commons/mail.asp?cons_id=53
The Blogs on this site represent the individual views of their authors and do not necessarily reflect the policies or practices of the National Union of Students.
All links in blogs will open in a new browser window.
The permanent URL for this specific blog entry is: http://www.officeronline.co.uk/blogs/jamesj/272319.aspx
|